Providing a Model for Ensuring Citizens’ Rights in Tehran Municipality

Authors

    Sepideh Moazen Department of Public Administration, ST.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
    Pejman Salehi * Department of Public Administration, ST.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran p_salehi@azad.ac.ir
    Mohammad Ahmadian Department of Public Administration, ST.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

Keywords:

Citizens’ rights, urban management, Tehran Municipality, good governance, transparency, accountability, structural equation modeling

Abstract

The realization of citizens’ rights within administrative systems, particularly in urban management, is regarded as one of the principal indicators of good governance, transparency, and accountability. The objective of this study was to design and validate a model for ensuring citizens’ rights in Tehran Municipality and to identify the dimensions and components influencing it. In terms of purpose, this research is applied, and in terms of approach, it adopts a mixed-methods (qualitative–quantitative) design. In the qualitative phase, the initial dimensions of the model were identified through a systematic review and thematic analysis and were subsequently refined through semi-structured interviews with experts in public law and urban management. In the quantitative phase, the extracted model was tested using a descriptive–survey method and structural equation modeling among staff members of the central administrative units of Tehran Municipality. Convergent and discriminant validity were assessed through the Average Variance Extracted (AVE) index and the Fornell–Larcker criterion, respectively, and reliability was examined and confirmed using Cronbach’s alpha and composite reliability. The results indicated that the “level of awareness of citizens’ rights” (β = 0.76), “implementation of policies and citizens’ rights” (β = 0.76), and “behavior and experience” (β = 0.72) exerted the greatest influence on ensuring citizens’ rights. Moreover, monitoring and evaluation mechanisms, organizational structure, organizational culture, and follow-up strategies demonstrated positive and statistically significant effects (p < 0.01). At the descriptive level, transparency in executive practices showed the highest mean among employees, whereas experiential learning exhibited the lowest mean among citizens. The findings suggest that the realization of citizens’ rights in Tehran Municipality requires synergy among awareness, effective policy implementation, professional employee conduct, efficient oversight, and a responsive organizational culture. Moving beyond purely legal frameworks toward the practical and lived experiences of citizens constitutes the most important strategy for enhancing citizens’ rights in urban management.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

1. Rahmani P, Taleb T. An Inquiry into Citizenship Rights. Tehran: Asar Fekr Publications; 2019 1398.

2. Khosravi H. Introduction to the Basics of Citizenship Rights. Tehran: Payame Noor University Press; 2022 1401.

3. Andreouli E, Figgou L, Kadianaki I. Citizenship in social and political psychology: A relational and future‐oriented framework for the study of everyday citizenship practice. Political Psychology. 2025.

4. Heidari E, Heidarpour J, Rajaei M. The Essence of Citizenship Rights and Strategies for Its Generalization in Society. Religion and Law Quarterly. 2023;11(39):25-49.

5. Shafiei Alavijeh M, Mirhosseini SM, Emadzadeh MK. Analysis of the Challenges of Protecting Citizenship Rights in Iran; A Case Study of the Judiciary Institution. Quarterly Journal of Public Law Studies, University of Tehran. 2025;55(1):539-66.

6. Shafiei Alavijeh M, Mirhosseini SM, Emadzadeh MK. Analysis of the Obstacles and Challenges of the Judiciary in Protecting Public Rights. Mizan Journal of Public Law. 2024;1(1):25-40.

7. Izadi V. Investigating the Impact of Citizenship Rights on Urban Management: A Case Study of Shahrekord City. Scientific Journal of New Research Approaches in Management and Accounting. 2022;6(20):2291-7.

8. Mardani R. The Role of Iranian Municipalities in Educating Citizenship Rights and Duties: Allameh Tabataba'i University; 2022.

9. Salmani Z, Sharifi A, Farkish H. Investigating the Challenges of Implementing Citizenship Rights in Iran's Administrative System Based on Good Governance Components. 2024;54(3):1409-33.

10. Salyani M, Fallahzadeh Abarghouei MA, Motazedian R. Citizenship Rights in the Administrative System: An Analysis of Implementation Challenges. Administrative Law. 2019;7(20):147-76.

11. Besley T, Burgess R, Khan A, Xu G. Bureaucracy and development. Annual Review of Economics. 2022;14(1):397-424. doi: 10.1146/annurev-economics-080521-011950.

12. Asif M. Understanding the Changing Dynamics of Governance: A Case Study of Pakistan. Pakistan Social Sciences Review. 2024;8(2):451-62.

13. Sabahi Garaghani M, Ranjbari A, Masoud G. Doctrinal and Legal Foundations for the Observance of Citizenship Rights with a Look at Iran's Administrative System. Theological Doctrinal Research (Islamic Sciences). 2018;8(32):295-321.

14. Afshar Ahmadi I, Rouhani Moghadam M, Aghaei Bejestani M. The Position of Individual Citizenship Rights in Jurisprudence and the Legal System of Iran. Scientific Research Journal of Medical Law. 2019;13(5):7-22.

15. Rafiei M, Barzegar A, Hosseini Sadrabadi I. Structural and Normative Priorities of the Legislative Process in Iran. Islamic Revolution Approach. 2022;16(58):87-110.

16. Moslemkhani M. Investigating the Duties of Quasi-Judicial Authorities of Municipalities in Relation to Citizenship Rights: Islamic Azad University, Tehran Central Branch; 2023.

17. Haghi N, Safari H. Sociological Analysis of Awareness of Citizenship Rights (Case Study: Meshgin Shahr City). Iranian Journal of Political Sociology. 2022;5(1):691-708.

18. Cheraghi M, Mojibi T, Daneshfard K. Designing a Model of Participation in Problem Identification in the Policymaking of the Educational System in Line with the Protection of Citizenship Rights. Sociology of Education. 2024;10(2):162-75.

19. Roqhaniyan Z, Tavafi H. A Synthesis Research on the Indicators and Components of Citizenship Rights and Providing a Comprehensive Model for Its Realization. Political-Social Studies of Iranian History and Culture. 2025;4(3):25-40.

20. Ahsan AK, Chakma B, Panday PK, Huque AS, Prodip MA. Does Implementation of 'Citizen's Charter Make Any Difference in Service Delivery? Comparing the Performance of Local Councils between Plain and Hilly Areas-A Case of Bangladesh. SAGE Open. 2024;14(2):21582440241258291. doi: 10.1177/21582440241258291.

21. Sohrabi A, Nazmohammadi Shahrejerdi M, Jandaghi G, Akhavan SH. Pathology of the Implementation of the Client Respect Plan in Government Organizations (Case Study: Government Organizations of Qom City). Scientific Journal of Business Strategies. 2020;9(47):479-99.

22. Alblooshi T, Azli M, Hilmi MF, Abudaqa A, Ahmed G. Examining the trends in citizen satisfaction towards e-government services in United Arab Emirates: a structural equation modelling approach. International Journal of Services, Economics and Management. 2023;14(1):58-77. doi: 10.1504/IJSEM.2023.129597.

23. Akhoundi M. Analysis and Recognition of Public Relations and Electronic Municipality in the Financial-Administrative Management System of Municipalities. Accounting and Management Perspective. 2024;7(99):151-62.

24. Akrami R. Methodological or Substantive Validity of Criminal Confession in the Laws of Islamic Countries with Emphasis on Iranian Law. The Judiciary's Law Journal. 2020;84(112):25-49.

25. Camacho LJ, Salazar-Concha C. Corporate citizenship: toward an extended understanding of the relationship between economic and legal citizenship. Journal of Economics Studies and Research. 2020;472317.

26. Camacho LJ. Bridging Organizational Citizenship Behavior and Corporate Citizenship as a Pathway to Effective ESG Performance. Businesses. 2025;5(3):38. doi: 10.3390/businesses5030038.

27. Camoletto S, Montes‐Sancho MJ, Santini E. Multinational corporations and their corporate citizenships: exploring their effects on corporate performance under different legal traditions. Journal of Public Affairs. 2024;24(3):e2942. doi: 10.1002/pa.2942.

28. Cabot H. On the doorstep of Europe: Asylum and citizenship in Greece: University of Pennsylvania Press; 2023.

29. Bertrand G. Quand l'étranger est le Français qui voyage. Voyager en Italie en temps de révolution (années 1780-années 1800). La Révolution française. 2022(22).

30. Salmani Z, Sharifi A, Farkish H. Investigating the Challenges of Implementing Citizenship Rights in Iran's Administrative System Based on Good Governance Components. Quarterly Journal of Public Law Studies, University of Tehran. 2024;54(3):1409-33.

31. Motazedian R, Ahmadabadi R. Identification and Analysis of Drivers Affecting Citizenship Rights in the Administrative System. Administrative Law. 2022;9(31):192-213.

32. Taheri A, Tabatabaei SMS. Explaining Strategies to Combat Judicial Corruption in Iran's Civil Procedure System. Private Law Studies. 2020;50(2):285-302.

33. Khashe MH, Samadi MN. Social and Situational Strategies for Preventing Judge Corruption in Jurisprudence. Biannual Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology Findings. 2021;1(1):115-36.

34. Ziyaei MA, Shafeipour A. The Ruling on Gifts to Judges in Iranian Statutory Laws. Judicial Quarterly. 2018;18(93):121-38.

Downloads

Published

2026-03-10

Submitted

2025-11-10

Revised

2026-02-12

Accepted

2026-02-19

Issue

Section

Articles

How to Cite

Moazen, S. ., Salehi, P., & Ahmadian, M. . (2026). Providing a Model for Ensuring Citizens’ Rights in Tehran Municipality. Journal of Management and Business Solutions. https://journalmbs.com/index.php/jmbs/article/view/226

Similar Articles

1-10 of 153

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.